NCARB Vignette - 1st Attempt

[dinar]

First attempt at NCARB's Vignette, please comment! Thank you!!

[Sparky83]

Incorrect spacing for all 2x4 lighs.
Rigid duct layout does not allow for flexibility in diffuser locations with a max 10' flex.
Uneven HVAC layout in the studio.
NO air movement on the west side of the architect's office.
Insufficient accent lights.
Return in the file room will fall out.

[dinar]

Thanks for the feedback! Would you mind pointing out why the 2x4 lights are incorrectly spaced? Shouldn't it be 4' max?

How are the HVAC layout uneven? I can see the reception room looking uneven, but the rest looks fine to me.

I see that the NCARB solution has 4 accent likes, but I spaced each accent likes 4' max. Is that incorrect?

Do the return component have to fit nicely in a 2x4 ceiling tile?

Thanks!

[Sparky83]

Thanks for the feedback! Would you mind pointing out why the 2x4 lights are incorrectly spaced? Shouldn't it be 4' max? You must use both lighting charts for 2x4 lights.

How are the HVAC layout uneven? I can see the reception room looking uneven, but the rest looks fine to me. Think symmetry.

I see that the NCARB solution has 4 accent likes, but I spaced each accent likes 4' max. Is that incorrect? Yes it is incorrect.

Do the return component have to fit nicely in a 2x4 ceiling tile? Needs support on 3 sides so they won't fall out.

Thanks!

Go here for more info on accent lights:
viewtopic.php?f=9&t=1610