Alt Vignette Attempts

[DTH]

Hey All,

Please take a look at these two attempts at the alternate vignette.

I used the NCARB 4.0 program and lighting spacing for the first attempt. I placed the accent lighting on the west wall of the waiting area since there was architects office.

For the second attempt, NCARB program but challenged myself to use a light fixture spacing that wasn't even. Instead of 2'-0" in the long direction of the 2x4's, I used 2'-6" which meant a 5'-0" spacing. I also used 2'-6" for the 2x2's. This way I had to choose between making the space between the fixtures either overlit slightly, or underlit.

My initial concern with the second attempt is that I didn't align the rigid duct on center with the supply - would that be fatal?

Thanks for any and all help / comments.

[kotharin78]

Hi, I might tries the ALTs this weekend and reply to your attempts and post my own-- hopefully before you take the test. I really like doing the ALTs more than the Kaplan Vignettes... but I might run out of time. Goodluck