BL 1st Attempt

[r1st808]

Here's my first crack at the BL vignette. Comments are greatly appreciated!

ARE SD Fl1 Vignette 1.JPG

ARE SD Fl2 Vignette 1.JPG

[Sparky83]

Double doors are a waste of time. Egress capacity is not in the scope of this vignette.
A direct connection between TS and MP is not in the program.
Cannot see any visual control windows in R.
EE has no door.
MP does not need windows in the east or west walls.
Do R, CR and W have exterior windows?
SM has no door.
TR's do not have to stack.

[r1st808]

Hi Sparky83, thanks much for the feedback.

Double doors are a waste of time. Egress capacity is not in the scope of this vignette. Understood.
A direct connection between TS and MP is not in the program. Do you think this would be penalized? "Direct Access" in lieu of "Near"?
Cannot see any visual control windows in R. Yes, I didn't think you could do interior windows, but after looking at other people's solutions, I understand that's the way to meet the "visual control" requirement.
EE has no door. Totally forgot to put that door between EM & EE.
MP does not need windows in the east or west walls. Understood. Need to avoid such additions from "design instinct"!
Do R, CR and W have exterior windows? Yes, just hard to see because of poor image quality and walls being right on setback line.
SM has no door. I moved the room after placing windows and doors, and the doors disappeared. Will note that moving rooms after doors are placed requires putting in new doors.
TR's do not have to stack.Understood.

[Sparky83]

Hi Sparky83, thanks much for the feedback.

Double doors are a waste of time. Egress capacity is not in the scope of this vignette. Understood.
A direct connection between TS and MP is not in the program. Do you think this would be penalized? "Direct Access" in lieu of "Near"? Adding things not in the progra won't help and could hurt. Direct connection is not near".
Cannot see any visual control windows in R. Yes, I didn't think you could do interior windows, but after looking at other people's solutions, I understand that's the way to meet the "visual control" requirement.
EE has no door. Totally forgot to put that door between EM & EE.
MP does not need windows in the east or west walls. Understood. Need to avoid such additions from "design instinct"!
Do R, CR and W have exterior windows? Yes, just hard to see because of poor image quality and walls being right on setback line.
SM has no door. I moved the room after placing windows and doors, and the doors disappeared. Will note that moving rooms after doors are placed requires putting in new doors.
TR's do not have to stack.Understood.

[exams4ever]

You don't need direct connection ( door) between EM and EE. It is not in the program. Also, EE needs to be accessible from the corridor. ALL rooms needs to be accessible from the corridor ( with or without direct connection with any other space) as per the program.

[Sparky83]

You don't need direct connection ( door) between EM and EE. It is not in the program. Also, EE needs to be accessible from the corridor. ALL rooms needs to be accessible from the corridor ( with or without direct connection with any other space) as per the program.

You might want to read the program again, and EE must have a door.