Site Design 3 attempts

[Calisti]

Please let me know if you see anything wrong with my three Site design attempts.

1.Does the walkway have to be drawn at the handicap spaces or can the plaza abut the Handicap spaces?

2. Does the walkway have to cross over the entry of the buildings to touch the plaza or can the entry separate the plaza and walkway and still create a continuous path?

3.It the service properly blocked from the PP on the third design?. Thanks

[Sparky83]

Please let me know if you see anything wrong with my three Site design attempts.

1.Does the walkway have to be drawn at the handicap spaces or can the plaza abut the Handicap spaces? Walks and the PP are both pedestrian circulation.

2. Does the walkway have to cross over the entry of the buildings to touch the plaza or can the entry separate the plaza and walkway and still create a continuous path? It would be better to overlap the OT entry with the PP.

3.It the service properly blocked from the PP on the third design?. Blocked from what? Thanks

A walk running along the edge of the PP is redundant. "minimize paving" is a program requirement.
Inadequate building separation.
Forcing service vehicles through the parking area is poor design logic.

[Calisti]

Thank you for your review.
to clarify this:
3.It the service properly blocked from the PP on the third design?. Blocked from what? Thanks
Program states:
"4. The view of the service entrance to the restaurant shall be blocked from the pedestrian Plaza.... by buildings or trees as appropriate."
Therefore, Is the tree planted adjacent to the service of the restaurant sufficient? or is it not needed as I have seen other solutions without it. Thanks in advance.

[Sparky83]

Thank you for your review.
to clarify this:
3.It the service properly blocked from the PP on the third design?. Blocked from what? Thanks
Program states:
"4. The view of the service entrance to the restaurant shall be blocked from the pedestrian Plaza.... by buildings or trees as appropriate."
Therefore, Is the tree planted adjacent to the service of the restaurant sufficient? or is it not needed as I have seen other solutions without it. Thanks in advance.

Not needed at all unless you can see through building or around corners.